TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
House Beautiful reports that some designers are steering clients toward natural stone and porcelain instead of engineered quartz. The shift is a reported design preference, not evidence that quartz is disappearing nationally; California’s reported plans for restrictions are tied to silica exposure risks for fabricators.
Some interior designers are recommending quartzite, soapstone, granite and porcelain instead of engineered quartz for kitchen projects, according to a House Beautiful report. The shift reflects changing design preferences and concerns about fabrication workers’ exposure to crystalline silica, but the report does not establish that quartz is broadly being phased out or that a nationwide ban is planned.
The report cites the National Kitchen & Bath Association’s annual trend report as showing that 78 percent of designers are sourcing quartzite, while fewer individuals are selecting quartz. It does not provide the survey’s sample size, a comparison figure for earlier years, or further details on how the sourcing measure was defined. The percentage signals interest in quartzite, but by itself does not show that quartz has lost a particular share of the countertop market.
Designers interviewed by House Beautiful gave different reasons for recommending alternatives. Barrett Oswald, an interior designer in New York’s Westchester County, said quartz’s durability, consistency and low maintenance have appeal, but that she finds it lacks the depth, warmth and individuality of natural stone. Kilian Camp of San Diego-based Élan Design House said clients who see natural-stone slabs and learn about their performance often choose real stone for kitchens and primary bathrooms.
Other designers cautioned against treating quartz as stain-proof. Jessica Risko Smith, based in Santa Barbara, said some clients expect a “bulletproof” surface and can be disappointed. Steven Cooper of Cooper Pacific Kitchens in West Hollywood summed up the distinction: quartz is “stain-resistant, not stain-proof.” The report also notes that California is reportedly preparing to restrict engineered-quartz production because of occupational health concerns linked to crystalline silica; it does not give a proposed rule, timetable or official source for that account.
Choices for Kitchen Renovations
Countertops are a costly, disruptive part of a kitchen renovation, so a shift in designer recommendations could affect what homeowners compare before committing to a material. The alternatives do not offer identical trade-offs: natural stone can develop patina and may need more care, while porcelain is presented by the designers as a durable option that can suit tighter budgets. Homeowners should compare specific products and maintenance guidance rather than assume any surface is indestructible.
The reported silica issue matters beyond appearance and upkeep. Engineered-stone fabrication can expose workers to crystalline silica, which has been linked to silicosis, a serious lung disease. The article’s account of California preparations points to a possible regulatory dimension, but readers should not treat it as confirmation that a final ban is in effect. The practical impact depends on what policymakers propose and whether other jurisdictions take similar action.
Products Worth Considering
Bose S1 Pro+ Portable PA Speaker
Dreame H15 Pro Wet-Dry Vacuum and Mop
Philips Hue Secure Wired Video Doorbell, 2K, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Why Designers Reconsider Quartz
Engineered quartz became a popular countertop choice because it combines a consistent appearance with a reputation for durability and relatively low maintenance. Designers interviewed for the House Beautiful report say some clients are now more interested in the variation and aging of natural materials than in surfaces designed to look uniform over time. That is a reported shift among professionals and clients, not proof that quartz has disappeared from showrooms or fallen out of use across the country.
The alternatives named in the report vary. Oswald and Camp point to marble and quartzite for their natural appearance, while Smith recommends soapstone and granite for clients seeking lower-maintenance natural-stone choices. Camp and Cooper recommend porcelain slabs when cost or use in places such as showers and fireplaces is a concern. These are designers’ recommendations, not a comparative product test; the article does not provide prices, performance ratings or maintenance schedules.
““We’ve always felt that quartz lacks the depth, warmth, and individuality of natural stone.””
— Barrett Oswald, interior designer in New York’s Westchester County, as quoted by House Beautiful
Market Shift and California Rules
The available material does not establish how much quartz sales or installations have changed, or whether the reported designer sourcing figure represents a rise from a previous year. It also does not show that homeowners generally are abandoning quartz. The headline claim that quartz may be “on its way out” is stronger than the evidence in the report supports: the documented development is a set of designer observations and a reported preference for alternatives.
The California policy account remains limited. House Beautiful says the state is reportedly preparing to ban engineered-quartz production, but the supplied report identifies no bill, agency proposal, official announcement, effective date or confirmed scope. It is also unclear whether restrictions would cover all engineered stone, apply only to production, or extend to other activities. The silica hazard is a worker-safety concern; the report does not provide details on exposure levels or specific regulatory findings.
Watch for Policy and Market Evidence
Readers considering a renovation can ask fabricators and suppliers about the material’s composition, care requirements, warranty and safety practices. Anyone comparing natural stone with porcelain should review the specific slab and its recommended maintenance rather than relying only on broad claims about durability. The report offers no forecast for when quartz might lose more market share, and it does not identify a deadline for any California policy.
The next concrete developments to watch are an official California proposal or rule, if one is issued, and future industry data that shows whether preferences are changing over time. Until those details are available, quartz’s supposed decline should be understood as a reported design trend—not a confirmed nationwide replacement.
Key Questions
Is quartz being banned across the United States?
No nationwide ban is established in the report. It says California is reportedly preparing to restrict engineered-quartz production, but provides no official proposal or confirmed timetable.
What materials are designers recommending instead?
The report names quartzite, marble, soapstone, granite and porcelain. Designers’ recommendations vary according to budget, appearance and maintenance preferences.
Does quartz stain?
The designers quoted describe quartz as stain-resistant rather than stain-proof. Performance can depend on the product and use, so buyers should consult manufacturer care instructions.
Why is engineered quartz linked to worker safety concerns?
The report says crystalline silica in engineered stone has been linked to silicosis among workers. It does not detail exposure levels or a specific California rule, so the policy status remains unconfirmed in the supplied material.
Source: housebeautiful.com
